Researching OnFife museums’ African Collections
Curator stories

Researching OnFife museums’ African Collections

21 October 2024 8 min read

Over the past couple of years our Collections Curator, Kirke, has been working on improving our knowledge of OnFife museums’ African collections as part of National Museums Scotland’s nationwide partnership project Reveal and Connect. In this blog, she gives a brief overview of her work so far.  

The aim of the Reveal and Connect project is to ‘publish a review of African and Caribbean collections in Scottish museums, and to develop guidance and training materials to support museums and communities to gain the knowledge and confidence to understand, care for and make best use of these collections’. OnFife museums hold no significant material from the Caribbean, but we have over 270 artefacts from Africa in our care – some of which were examined during a research visit by the Reveal and Connect project curator in 2023.    

One of my initial tasks when this project started was to try and find out more about the provenance of these collections and add any missing information (from old registers, documents and letters) to our collections management system (database). However, similarly to other museums, the information we hold about some objects, including by whom and when they were given to us, is very limited or in some cases missing completely.  What complicates matters further is that some of these artefacts were not given directly to our museum services but were transferred from third party organisations at a later date. This was the case, for example, with the Duncan Institute in Cupar which was established in 1870. The Duncan Institute’s collections came into our care more than a century later – in 1975. In turn, the Duncan Institute acquired the collection of James Bonnar’s Castlehill School museum in Cupar in 1923-24. Both institutions collected world cultures material independently from each other. However, so far, I have not found an original inventory list for these collections, so it is difficult to say exactly when or by whom each of the objects was collected.

Objects in Laing Museum in Newburgh were mainly bequeathed to the town by Alexander Laing in 1892. However, we know that other donors also added to the museum’s collection thereafter (more about this later). Similarly to Cupar, I have found no original inventory of the collections that would specify which objects came from Alexander Laing and which were later additions.

On some occasions, articles from old newspapers came to my assistance. The donation of the Zulu shield was reported in the Fife Herald, 10 April 1879, under the headline ‘Presentation of Zulu weapons of war to Duncan Institute’. The article gives a brief description of the shield (and five assegais, or spears) and credits them as a gift from George Lindsay Bonnar (formerly from Cupar). It is not clear how the shield came into Bonnar’s possession. The article mentions that it had been ‘used in actual warfare’ which could indicate that it was acquired during the Anglo-Zulu War of 1879.     

Image: Zulu shield (CUPMS:1984.0279) was gifted to Duncan Institute, Cupar, in 1879. Zulu shields and weapons were collected and displayed by numerous institutions in Scotland and England that year due to Anglo-Zulu War.

During her visit to our Collections Centre in January 2023, the Reveal and Connect project curator viewed and photographed 40 objects more closely. Information about these artefacts has now been shared with specialist curators and partnering researchers and groups around the world who will hopefully help us find out more about these objects in the future.  

Some of the most significant material in the Laing Museum in Newburgh comes from Zambia and was donated by Robert Andrew Young (1867-1932). Young was born in Newburgh and moved to southern Africa in 1890. In 1901, he was appointed ‘Native Commissioner’ whose tasks included tax collection and hearing grievances, which brought him into contact with many local people. Over the years, Young sent various artefacts to the Laing Museum, including swords, arrows, charms, cups, water-bottles and bracelets. Unfortunately, only a small number of these have been identified, mainly thanks to information from Young’s personal diaries (a copy of which has kindly been shared with us by his family members).  

The most noteworthy of these artefacts is the Tabwa throne or chair, which is presumed to be one of only eight similar objects known to exist in the world. Chairs of this type are thought to have been status objects for high-ranking people and were produced for a short period of time from around 1850 to 1880. Young’s diary states that it was gifted to him on 1 December 1901: ‘[Chief] Matipa presented me with a curious stool with a high back and carved all over and on top the high back the figure of a man carved out of one solid piece of wood. The man who carves the stools, figures etc. has promised to carve some figures for me’. Although we hold some information about the chair, there is still so much to learn about it – we do not know anything about the artisan who made it, nor its original owners, nor Young’s relationships with local people in the wider context of colonial structures. 

Image: back of Tabwa throne (NEGLM:1981.0005) which features balamwezi triangular patterns, decorated with red and white pigmentation that are thought to reference the rising of the new moon and lunar phases.

 

A small armlet of blue, green and black beads has a very different provenance story. The armlet was most likely displayed at James Bonnar’s museum as it was attached to a display label, signed by James Bonnar. The label describes how his brother, John W Bonnar, commanded the Abalondolozi regiment of the Amahlengwoni Zulus during the so-called ‘Basuto War’ (1880-81), and how the armlet was looted from the body of a soldier from Lesotho who was killed in the Orange River region. I have decided not to include a photograph of the armlet in this blog but only show the label that tells its shocking story. It is impossible to identify the owner of this armlet, but perhaps one day it may find its way back to its source community.  

Image: Early 20th century display label for Zulu armlet (CUPMS:1992.0059).

In addition to recording the provenance of our collections, another aim of this project has been to understand the objects better and to improve the terminology used to describe them. This Nkisi figure from Lower Congo (around mouth of Zaire; Bakongo or Mayombe tribes) was originally labelled and catalogued as a ‘fetish’ figure – a European term which evolved from a condescending misinterpretation of African cultures. The Nkisi figures’ powers were ministered by a priest (nganga) as part of a ceremony during which items to convey a curse or offer protection were placed in the figure’s body cavity.  

Image: Nkisi figure (CUPMS:1992.0200) and its old label, describing it as ‘Smallpox fetish from the Upper Congo’.

The ‘Janiform mask’ from Kirkcaldy Galleries collection is a further example of this (‘Janiform’ being a European term derived from the name of a Roman god, Janus, for describing two-faced objects like this mask which has faces on both sides). This mask from Nigeria is typically associated with the Ejagham (Ekoi) people.  

Image: Two-faced mask (KIRMG:1927.0226) worn during ceremonies (such as warrior initiations and commemorative funerals). The masquerade performances are thought to create a continuum between the living and the spirits of their deceased ancestors, blending art, dance and ritual practises.

The aforementioned objects were collected as rare, individual pieces. However, some items such as arrow heads, spears, jewellery, cups etc were acquired by various people and in such high numbers that it is difficult to match them to a specific donor. Snuff containers were also popular collectors’ items in the 19th century. Although they were collected as ‘ethnographic native curios’, it is important to remember that tobacco was introduced to Africa by Europeans in the late 1500s. It gained widespread popularity, and African peoples developed distinctive modes of tobacco production and use. These containers are thus rooted in colonial connections. Snuff containers are only a small part of the legacy of the tobacco industry in Africa – details of which are too complex to cover in this blog.   

Image: examples of snuff bottles (CUPMS:1992.0064, CUPMS:1992.0073 and CUPMS:1992.0079). Similar containers were initially used for different purposes – such as storing medicine or perfume.

This blog is intended to provide just a small example of what has already been achieved during the Reveal and Connect project, and there is still a great task ahead. With more than 270 African objects in our care, OnFife museum service is committed to continuing our research into these collections to try and understand them better and make them more accessible to communities of interest.   

If you have any information about the origins of the Laing Museum’s or Duncan Institute’s African collections, please contact our collections team via museums.enquiries@onfife.com. 

We also invite people from black ethnic minority backgrounds in Fife who are interested in helping us develop a Collections Centre tour highlighting these collections to contact us via museums.enquiries@onfife.com

Region/country  Collection size estimate  Types of material 
Africa unspecified  51  Domestic utensils, tools, beadwork, stone knives and axes, weapons, snuff equipment, wooden figures
Southern Africa  78
Southern Africa unspecified 

Zulu 

Xhosa 

Lesotho

Armour, personal ornaments, beadwork, snuff equipment, club, clothing, domestic utensils
Central Africa  16
Central Africa unspecified  

Lunda 

Chokew 

weapons
Western Africa  5
Western Africa unspecified  2 Weapons, local currency
Democratic Republic of the Congo 

Bakongo 

2 Staff, Nkisi figure
Nigeria 

Ekoi 

1 Janiform skin-covered mask
Eastern Africa  21
Eastern Africa unspecified  5 Personal ornaments
Kenya  9 Personal ornaments
Zambia 

Tabwa 

7 Chair, staff, wooden figures, weapons
Northern Africa  7
Northern Africa unspecified  Footwear, domestic utensils, stone tools

 

Help us keep improving

You're at the heart of what we do. Your feedback helps us improve our venues and experiences for everyone.